HOT TOPICS ▶ Honduras Elections     Target: Iran     The Real Baltimore     Reality Asserts Itself     United Kingdom    

  August 31, 2010


Israeli historian Tom Segev on the founding of the state of Israel
Members don't see ads. If you are a member, and you're seeing this appeal, click here


Share to Facebook Share to Twitter

I support TRNN because it is the closest expression of the ideal of a free press I have seen. - Daniel
Log in and tell us why you support TRNN


Tom Segev (Hebrew: תום שגב‎) is an Israeli historian, author and journalist. He is associated with Israel's New Historians, a group challenging many of the country's traditional narratives. He worked during the 1970s as a correspondent for Maariv in Bonn. and he was has been a visiting professor at Rutgers University, the University of California at Berkeley, and Northeastern University,


PAUL JAY, SENIOR EDITOR, TRNN: Welcome to To the Real News Network. I'm Paul Jay, coming to you today from Jerusalem. I'm now joined by Tom Segev. He's a renowned Israeli historian, contributor to the Israeli daily newspaper Haaretz. He's the author of the book 1967: Israel, the War and the Year That Transformed the Middle East. Thanks for joining us.


JAY: So, as we travel around the Middle East, we've been in Beirut and we've talked to Palestinian refugees, we've talked to historians and other people, and we get two basic narratives about where Israel came from. First narrative is persecuted Jews in Europe [inaudible] came to the Middle East. Some Jews were already living in the Middle East, persecuted by Arabs, and they needed a state to defend themselves from anti-Semitism, more or less on all sides. The other narrative which we hear as we travel, amongst some of the Arab historians and others, that Israel is a colonial project, began early in the 20th century, and this colonial project took advantage of the fact that Jews have been persecuted in Europe and some other places. So as a historian, what does the evidence—which version, which narrative does the evidence support?

SEGEV: You will hear both these narratives also in Israel [inaudible] Israelis. We argue about everything, and we also argue a lot about our history. I think that both these narratives are true and untrue at the same time. They don't really contradict as much as it seems when you pose the question. Jews for thousands of years cherished a hope to return to the land of Israel. That was the essence of Jewish religion and Jewish identity all over the world. The Zionist movement, which began sometime in the 19th century and transformed that age-long aspiration into a political ideology, and then actually into a political movement, was based on these ancient hopes. So that's no invention. Also, Jews had been persecuted wherever they lived. So that's no problem in history. When the Zionist movement looked for support, it looked for support among countries which [were], as most world powers were at that time, colonial powers. They looked for support in Germany and didn't get it, in Russia and didn't get it. They looked for support in France and didn't get it. Eventually they got support in England, which, of course, was the colonial power at the beginning of the 20th century, and the British supported the Zionist movement. That lasted for about 20 years.

JAY: And this is the Balfour Declaration.

SEGEV: This is the Balfour Declaration of 1917 stating that the British government views with favor the establishment of a national home for the Jews in Palestine, meaning, really, a Jewish state.

JAY: And why was it in the British interest to declare such a thing?

SEGEV: Many people thought that it wasn't, even then. Actually, when you go to the archives, you see that they abound with letters and reports and memos and telegrams, all coming from the British military stationed in Egypt, warning the British government: stay out of Palestine; Palestine means trouble; don't move into Palestine. And the politicians in London, the decision-makers in London, overruled the army and decided to support Zionism in spite of these warnings.

JAY: Now, for viewers that may not know this history—I hope I'm correct—at this time, the Ottoman Empire had broken up and the British had a mandate to—.

SEGEV: This was before the mandate. This was actually in World War I when the British had to decide: do we want to take Palestine and take upon ourselves the mandate to rule Palestine? They decided that they do. But then you would still wonder, well, let's assume that they have different views and they decided, yes, we do want to take Palestine. Why then support the Jews? Why support the weaker side? Why not support the Arabs? What the British did was to pretend that they're supporting both. In a way, they sold Palestine twice, once to the Arabs and once to the Jews. But still it is quite astonishing that they supported Zionism. And the reason why they did was out of a peculiar combination of very warm feelings for the Jews, very pro-Jewish feelings, religious feelings. These people in England, they were Christian Zionists. And at the same time, they feared the Jews and they despised the Jews, and they thought that it's better to have the Jews as allies than as enemies. So it's a combination between pro-Jewish and anti-Jewish.

JAY: To what extent do some of the more powerful Jewish families in Europe, like the Rothschilds, how much are they a part of what happened?

SEGEV: Many of the powerful families in Europe did not support Zionism at the time. In fact, most Jews never supported Zionism. And today most Jews support Zionism only because Zionism has reformulated its goals and nature. It no longer requires Jews to leave their countries and come to live in Israel. So we have accommodated, we have compromised the Zionist ideology, so that we don't lose the support of the Jews. But most Jews would rather stay in their countries.

JAY: But there's kind of a popular notion, at least, that the Rothschild family in particular helped finance a lot of early Zionism. Is that true?

SEGEV: Some of the Rothschilds did, yes. The Rothschild family is a large family, and some of the Rothschilds did support the early 19th century Jewish settlements, which were not necessarily Zionist settlements and were not necessarily or not consciously leading towards a Jewish state in Palestine.

JAY: I guess part of what I'm asking is, during this first part of the 20th century, is the Zionist conception project more from a Jewish elite or more from some socialist movement, working-class movement?

SEGEV: It is a very small movement. It is supported by masses of Jews in Eastern Europe and not so much by many Jews in Western Europe. So it's more a poor man's ideology, and also less—the people who supported Zionism were less assimilated into liberal modern society as they were in the West. So in Eastern Europe it had massive support, and in Western not so much. But most Jews—this is interesting—most Israelis are either people who have themselves or are the descendents of people who had never wanted to come to this country. They did not come out of Zionist ideology; they came as refugees. If you take my parents, for example, they came from Germany in 1935. They would have loved to stay in Germany, only they couldn't. The only reason why they stayed alive, the only reason why I am alive, is because they left Germany, Nazi Germany, in time. And where would they have gone? So, unwillingly, they chose a remote, primitive spot in Asia called Israel, called Palestine.

JAY: Well, in the next segment of our interview, let's talk about what your parents found when they got here in 1935 and how they were treated. Please join us for the next segment of our interview on The Real News Network.

End of Transcript

DISCLAIMER: Please note that transcripts for The Real News Network are typed from a recording of the program. TRNN cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.


Our automatic spam filter blocks comments with multiple links and multiple users using the same IP address. Please make thoughtful comments with minimal links using only one user name. If you think your comment has been mistakenly removed please email us at

latest stories

Paul Jay On Our Need For Monthly Donors
The Death of Detective Sean Suiter: How Deep Does the Corruption Go?
Undoing the New Deal: Roosevelt Created A Social Safety Net, Not Socialism (pt3)
The Only Peace Process is Palestinian Freedom
A Chicago Alderman Introduced A Water Affordability Ordinance. Does Baltimore Need One Too?
State of Emergency Declared in Southern California
To Fight Crime We Must Address Root Causes, Says Mayor of Compton, CA
DNC's Unity Commission Further Dividing the Party
Children's Health Insurance Program to Expire Under GOP Tax Bill
Hariri's Unresignation is Saudi's Latest Failure
Palestinians Resist Israel and its US Enabler
Coal, Lies and Renewable Energy, Australian Style
Bernie Sanders and Ben Jealous Hold Healthcare Rally in Baltimore
Mystery Surrounding Detective's Death Heightens Mistrust of Police
Unlike US Embassy, Palestinians Will Not Be Moved
Greece Emerges from Economic Crisis with Increased Inequality
Reporter's Harassment Sparks a #MeToo Moment at WNYC
The Argument for Closing Low-Enrollment Schools is Wrong, Advocates Say
Undoing the New Deal: Truman's Cold War Buries Wallace and the Left (pt2)
Trump's 'Criminal' Jerusalem Move Could Backfire
Is Saudi Arabia Destroying Yemen to Plunder It?
A Semblance of Justice For Walter Scott
Senator Al Franken Resigns
Mayor Chokwe Lumumba Wants to Make Jackson the Most Radical City on the Planet
Bankrupt Greece Becomes a Major Military Spender and 'Sales Agent' for NATO
Residents Say Police Lockdown in Wake of Cop's Death is Unconstitutional
The Whole Bushel: It's Hard To Tell From Your Bio
Ben Jealous: Maryland Needs Medicare-for-All
Preemptive Strike on North Korea: Is Trump Wagging the Dog?
Trump's Jerusalem Embassy Move Was Long in the Works,, The Real News Network, Real News Network, The Real News, Real News, Real News For Real People, IWT are trademarks and service marks of Independent World Television inc. "The Real News" is the flagship show of IWT and The Real News Network.

All original content on this site is copyright of The Real News Network. Click here for more

Problems with this site? Please let us know

Web Design, Web Development and Managed Hosting